Friday night, the 14th of July, we went undercover – posing as “Fanilows” – accompanying out-of-town friends to see Barry Manilow. We didn’t know what to expect. Ticket prices were fairly high; bumping up around $250 each for our seats (we were comped). Our friends paid $1000 each. That’s right, ONE THOUSAND dollars. For this privilege they received a champagne reception with ol’ Barry before the show, professional, as well as casual photos with Barry, a private audience with BM, autographed programs, and (drum roll please) front row center seats. We were told that the proceeds from this go to his foundation. Interestingly, fans are allowed to purchase this package only once in their lifetime. Our friend, Laurie, was giddy from the thrill of it all.
Having never been huge Barry fans — Ursula has one old Barry vinyl and Ellen has one CD — we were skeptical. But, we were extremely impressed by the production value of the show. It flowed. It was funny. It was packed and the audience went wild. We admit we knew more of his songs than we knew we knew and we even liked several of them. Barry had a fantastic orchestra, talented back-up dancers/singers. The whole package.
From a Tom Jones perspective, here are our biased observations — too bad the chances are slim that Tom will actually see this:
Barry does a full-screen retrospective of his career before the show opens. It was great. It would be incredible to see some old clips of Tom sometime during his show. He certainly has plenty to choose from. The overall feeling we were left with after viewing the history of BM was that he’s had staying power. What about Tom? Wouldn’t you love to see clips from the 60s, 70s, 80s and 90s? What a treat that would be!
Barry has a new album out of songs from the 50s. He integrated them into the show without saying something like, “Here’s my new single.” He did an American Bandstand segment and morphed that into some of the songs from his new CD. Very eloquent. And elegant.
Costumes. Barry wore a black shirt and pants and changed into at least five different jackets. It worked with the mood of the music and was part of the show. Aren’t we all more than a little tired of the navy and black sequined shirts? We are.
Barry acknowledged his fans. Several times. Thanked them for supporting him throughout his career. He even pulled one girl up on stage to dance (a waltz) with him during one of the 50’s songs. It was sweet. Enough said.
Barry acknowledged his band. Several times and by name.
There were actual skits and scenery; writing and directing. He talked about how he started out and got to where he is. It was interesting. Tom has quite the story to tell. We’d love to hear more about it.
Finally, Barry was just 60 years old. He actually sang songs that were appropriate for his voice — which isn’t anything special — and his age. Now, we know Tom is always current. That’s terrific and keeps him interesting, helping him find new audiences. But, admit it, wouldn’t you love to see hear him sing a lovely, classic, Cole Porter tune? Or, how about bringing some of his classics (like Till) back, maybe with new arrangements as he did with I (Who Have Nothing)?
With Tom’s phenomenal pipes (the best in the world), there is a whole universe of choices from which he could take material. There are classic ballads or R&B. We recently viewed a clip from The Right Time which was done in the early 90’s. When Tom sang that Otis Redding classic, I’ve Been Loving You Too Long it brought on goosebumps. Leave Stoned In Love to the club set and come back to us. Yes, continue to sing great music — and, please, do an R&B album — and try new things but, always, get back to your musical roots, to the music you love.
Watching Manilow’s show, an audience member gets a real sense of the man’s importance; a sense that he has a special place in popular music. We’re not going to debate that point, but we must state unequivocally that Tom Jones absolutely does have a special place in popular music — the first “trans-Atlantic” TV show; the first single act to make it here during the British invasion; the first single act to play Madison Square Garden. And so on. Thus, his show merits this kind of ambiance — a frame of reference that, without being stuffy or pretentious, recognizes his incredible voice and his amazing 40+ years of making music.
Editorial over. Barry was good. Tom is so much better and his career is so much more extraordinary. What we would give to see Tom step out of his comfort zone and really produce something that rivals what his contemporaries — not “peers,” because he has no real peers — are serving up. Now, that would be something indeed!
—Ursula & Ellen